Federal Law > Hiring Employees > Immigration Reform and Control Act

Immigration Reform and Control Act


It is unlawful for employers to hire, recruit or refer for a fee, or continue to employ illegal immigrants under the terms of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA), and as subsequently amended.1 In addition to the above, the IRCA also requires employers to follow an employment eligibility verification procedure for every newly hired employee.

Employment Eligibility Verification. Employers must verify on a form provided by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) that the individual hired is not an unauthorized alien. The IRCA specifically outlines the types of documents employers may accept as evidence of employment eligibility.2 These verification requirements are outlined in the employment eligibility verification form I-9. You can download a copy of the I-9 form from the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services website.

The USCIS requires that the I-9 form be completed and that supporting documentation which establishes identity and eligibility for employment be obtained within three days of the employee commencing employment. If an employee is hired for fewer than three days, the I-9 form must be completed at the time of hire.

Retention of form I-9. Verification forms must be retained by recruiters and referrers for a fee for a period of three years after the date of recruiting or referral. In the case of the hiring of an individual, the verification forms must be retained for three years after the date of hire, or one year beyond the date of termination of the employee, whichever is greater.3 The USCIS may inspect the verification forms. Inspection officials do not need warrants or subpoenas to gain access to the records. However, they must give an employer three days advance notice. All aspects of the I-9 forms must be completed as required by the USCIS regulations. Sanctions may be imposed if any portion of the I-9 forms are not completed properly.

Sanctions. Employers that knowingly hire illegal aliens or that fail to take the required steps to verify the employment eligibility of new hires are subject to civil and criminal penalties under the employer sanctions provision of the law. Employers are subject to fines ranging from one hundred dollars to one thousand dollars for each individual with respect to whom such violation occurred.4 In addition, for each illegal alien hired, employers may be fined from two hundred fifty dollars to two thousand dollars for the first offense, two thousand dollars to five thousand dollars for a second offense, and three thousand dollars to ten thousand dollars for subsequent offenses.5 If an employer engages in a pattern or practice of violations of hiring illegal aliens, that employer could be fined up to three thousand dollars for each unauthorized alien and imprisonment of up to six months, or both.6

Discrimination Prohibitions. The IRCA also prohibits discrimination based on national origin or citizenship status.7 The penalties for discrimination under the IRCA include payment of back wages for up to two years plus penalties as defined by the Act. In addition, attorney fees may be awarded to the prevailing party, if the losing party's argument is without reasonable foundation in law and fact.8

Recommendations For Compliance
  1. Copy and retain all I-9 forms and supporting documentation.

  2. Do not make employment decisions based on an individual's accent, foreign appearance, or name.

  3. Do not ask individuals about their citizenship or where they were born.

  4. Examine the I-9 form carefully and make sure that all parts of the form are completed.

  5. Do not use verification documents that do not appear to be valid. The INS will assist you in determining what types of documents are valid.

  6. Keep all verification documents and I-9 forms for the required period of time.

  7. More information about the employment verification process and other employer-based immigration topics is available from the USCIS's I-9 Central by clicking here.


  1. Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986, 8 U.S.C. § 1324a.

  2. 8 U.S.C. § 1324a(b).

  3. 8 U.S.C. § 1324a(b)(3).

  4. 8 U.S.C. § 1324a(e)(5).

  5. 8 U.S.C. § 1324a(e)(4).

  6. 8 U.S.C. § 1324a(f).

  7. 8 U.S.C. § 1324b.

  8. 8 U.S.C. § 1324b(g) and (h).
Login to read more.

Related Articles

06/22/2022 Justice Department Settles With California-Based IT Recruiter to Resolve Hiring Discrimination Claim
03/19/2019 Home Improvement Contractor Discriminated Against Customers, Created Hostile Work Environment for Afghan Employee
10/16/2018 E-Verify Federal Contractor Webinar
09/10/2018 About E-Verify and Upcoming Webinars
05/14/2018 USCIS and the Justice Department Formalize Partnership to Protect U.S. Workers from Discrimination and Combat Fraud
04/16/2018 New E-Verify.gov Website a User-Friendly Source to Verify Employment Eligibility
03/08/2018 Settlement by Bakery for $94,167 for Back Wages and Penalties
11/06/2017 I-9 Video Vignettes
10/06/2017 New Research and App to Combat Child Labor and Modern Slavery
09/12/2017 Revised I-9 Effective September 18, 2017; Teleconference on September 13
07/20/2017 Revised Form I-9 Now Available
04/05/2017 DOL Announces Plans to Protect U.S. Workers from H-1B Program Discrimination
03/17/2017 USCIS Has Reached H-2B Cap for FY2017
03/16/2017 USCIS To Begin Accepting H-1B Petitions for FY2018 Cap on April 3, 2017
03/06/2017 USCIS Will Temporarily Suspend Premium Processing for H-1B Petitions
03/01/2017 USCIS Reissues Receipt Notices to Those Who Renewed EADs From July 21, 2016 to January 16, 2017
02/20/2017 USCIS Publishes Updated Handbook for Employers for Completing Form I-9
02/17/2017 Ninth Circuit Denies US DOJ Emergency Motion for Stay in Suspended Executive Order 13769
02/13/2017 USCIS Will Only Accept Current Forms After February 21
02/07/2017 USCIS Continues Adjudicating Applications in Light of the Restraining Order Placed Against the Executive Order Protecting the Nation
02/03/2017 USCIS Adopts New Rule About Retention of High-Skilled Workers
02/01/2017 Executive Order Suspends Entry to U.S. From Designated Countries and Suspends Refugee Program
01/24/2017 Employers Must Use Form I-9 Dated 11/14/2016 to Verity Identity and Work Eligibility
01/16/2017 USCIS Reaches Fiscal Year 2017 H-2B Cap
12/27/2016 H-2B Returning Worker Program Has Expired
12/20/2016 Department of Homeland Security Amends Regulations Governing T NonImmigrant Status for Victims of Human Trafficking
11/23/2016 USCIS Publishes Final Rule to Improve Employment-Based Nonimmigrant and Immigrant Visa Programs
11/17/2016 USCIS Publishes Revised Version of Form I-9
10/25/2016 USCIS Adjust Fees Required for Most Immigration Applications and Petitions
09/15/2016 USCIS Encourages Employers With Returning Workers to Identify These Workers and Provide H-2B Returning Worker Certification
09/01/2016 Minnesota Farm and Its Owner to Pay $576,707 for Violations of H-2A Visa Program
08/23/2016 Produce Company to Pay $270,000 in Back Wages and Penalties for Improper Payment to H-2A Temporary Workers
06/02/2016 USCIS Expands Virtual Assistant to Answer Questions in Spanish
05/20/2016 USCIS Reaches Fiscal Year 2016 Cap for New H-2B Worker Petitions With Start Date Before October 1, 2016
04/25/2016 USCIS to Begin Processing Premium H-1B Petitions
04/13/2016 USCIS Completed Computer-Generated Random Selection Process to Meet H-1B Cap
04/08/2016 USCIS Has Reached H-1B Cap for Fiscal Year 2017
04/06/2016 USCIS Continues Use of Current Form I-9
03/31/2016 Nursery Ordered to Pay $143,384 to Domestic Employees Who Were Paid Less than Foreign Workers Under the H-2A Program
03/29/2016 USCIS Publishes 30-Day Notice in Federal Register About Public Comments on Proposed Changes to Form I-9
03/24/2016 H-2B Cap Reached for First Half of FY 2016
03/17/2016 USCIS Will Begin Accepting H-1B Petitions Starting April 1, 2016
03/07/2016 Department of Homeland Security Launches New Process for Employers Seeking to Hire Workers Through Employment-Based Visas
02/11/2016 USCIS Defines Returning Workers Who Are to be Exempted from FY 2016 Annual H-2B Cap
02/02/2016 USCIS Reminds Employers About Complete Form I-9
01/13/2016 USCIS Increases Fees for Certain H-1B Petitioners
01/04/2016 USCIS Seeks Public Comments on Proposed Rule About Employment-Based Nonimmigrant and Immigrant Visa Programs
12/02/2015 USCIS Launches Virtual Assistant
11/25/2015 USCIS Publishes Notice in Federal Register About Proposed Changes to Form I-9
07/28/2015 USCIS Issues Memorandum on Final Guidance on When to File and Amended or New H-1B Petition After Matter of Simeo Solutions, LLC
07/07/2015 USCIS Launches New Promotional Materials to Provide Information About the Naturalization Process
06/16/2015 USCIS Has Reached Second Half of FY 2015 H-2B Cap
06/11/2015 Farm Labor Contractor to Pay $320,000 in Civil Penalties for Discrimination Based on Citizenship Status in Violation of the INA
06/09/2015 USCIS Reopens 2015 Cap on H-2B Workers
05/27/2015 USCIS Begins Allowing Some H-4 Dependent Spouses to Apply for Employment Authorization
05/20/2015 USCIS to Temporarily Suspend Processing H-1B Extensions of Stay Petitions
04/29/2015 Department of Labor and Homeland Security Department Announce Interim Final Rule to Make Improvements to the H-2B Program
04/27/2015 E-Verify Is Now Available Nationwide
04/20/2015 USCIS to Continue Issuing Temporary Labor Certification Under H-2B and Will Resume Accepting Premium Processing Requests
04/14/2015 USCIS Has Selected Petitions to Meet the H-1B Cap for FY2016
04/10/2015 $322,094 in Back Wages and Penalties for Violations of the H-1B Visa Program
04/09/2015 H-1B Cap for FY2016 Has Been Reached
03/25/2015 USCIS Posts Updated Policy Memorandum on L-1B Nonimmigrant Visa Classification
03/19/2015 District Court Grants Motion Allowing Department of Labor to Issue Temporary Labor Certifications under H-2B Visa Program
03/13/2015 USCIS Will Begin Accepting H1-B Petitions for FY2016 on April 1
03/10/2015 USCIS Temporarily Suspends Adjudication of Form I-129 H-2B Petitions
02/25/2015 USCIS Extends Eligibility for Employment to Certain H-4 Dependent Spouses
02/23/2015 Judge Issues Injunction in Implementation of President's Executive Actions on Immigration
02/04/2015 USCIS Reaches Fiscal Year 2015 H-2B Cap
11/24/2014 President Obama Issues Executive Initiatives on Illegal Immigration
10/10/2014 USCIS Launches my-Everify for Employees
09/09/2014 Landscaping Company Violated H-2B Program and Must Pay $300,000 in Back Wages and Penalties
04/29/2014 USCIS H-1B Premium Processing to Begin April 28
04/08/2014 USCIS Reaches Fiscal Year 2015 H-1B Cap on April 7, 2014
03/26/2014 USCIS to Begin Accepting H-1B Petitions for FY2015 Starting April 1, 2014
03/05/2014 USCIS Observes System Use and Gives Tips on Following E-Verify Instructions
02/11/2014 USCIS Releases Videos to Help Employers and Employees With Form I-9
02/05/2014 USCIS Releases Revised Form N-400, Application for Naturalization
01/31/2014 Company to Pay $248,000 in Back Wages and Penalties for Violations of FLSA and H-2B Nonimmigrant Worker Provisions
01/27/2014 E-Verify Serves over 500,000 Companies, USCIS Updates E-Verify Website
01/20/2014 USCIS Announces Countries Whose Nations Are Eligible to Participate in H-2A and H-2B Visa Programs
12/09/2013 USCIS and Executive Office for Immigration Review Processes altered by ABT Settlement
12/04/2013 USCIS Revises Posters to Require Less Ink
11/25/2013 USCIS Adds Enhancement to E-Verify Program to Help Combat Identity Fraud
10/31/2013 USCIS Redesigns Website to Make It More User-Friendly
10/30/2013 USCIS Offers Spanish Language Webinar About E-Verify for Employers
10/21/2013 USCIS Resumes Its E-Verify Service
10/02/2013 Government Agencies Have Limited Activities During Government Shutdown
08/22/2013 Ohio Company Debarred from Participating in H-2B Visa Program and Agrees to Pay over $268,000 in Back Wages for Wage and Hour Violations
08/15/2013 USCIS Improves Forms and Technology
08/06/2013 USCIS Seeking Volunteers to Review Enhanced I-9 Form
07/31/2013 USCIS Posts FAQs in Response to Recent Supreme Court DOMA Decision
07/18/2013 Memorandum of Understanding Between Justice Department and NLRB to Coordinate Anti-Discrimination Based on National Origin or Citizenship Status
07/02/2013 USCIS Offers Enhanced Service to Employees Through E-Verify
05/06/2013 Department of Homeland Security and Department of Labor Have Jointly Published an Interim Final Rule for Wages for Temporary Non-Agricultural Employment
04/29/2013 USCIS to Hold Teleconference Addressing Revisions to the Employment Eligibility Verification Form I-9
04/16/2013 US Citizenship and Immigration Services Will Implement Verification System Requiring Biometric Data
04/08/2013 US Citizenship and Immigration Service Reached Fiscal Year 2014 H-1B Cap
04/03/2013 USCIS Suspends Adjudication of H-2B Petitions, DOL to Revise Wage Rule
03/25/2013 EEOC Launches Twitter Handle in Spanish and YouTube Channel
03/21/2013 H-1B Processing for Fiscal Year 2014 Begins April 1, 2013
02/26/2013 U.S. Citizenship and Immigrations Services' E-Verify Given High Marks In Customer Survey
12/10/2012 $82,200 in Back Wages and Penalties for Violations of the Immigration and Nationality Act by Ice Cream Company
11/01/2012 E-Verify Toolkit and Overview for Employees
03/28/2012 U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services is Seeking Public comment about Revisions to the I-9 Form for Employment Eligibility Verification
07/01/2011 Supreme Court: Arizona's "Legal Arizona Workers Act" Not Preempted by Federal Law
05/27/2011 US Citizenship and Immigration Services Unveiled I-9 Central on Its Website
03/24/2011 Department of Homeland Security and the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service Launch E-Verify Self Check
12/08/2010 $638,000 in Back Wages Recovered in Immigration Case; How Can You Avoid This?
08/06/2010 DOL Debars Asian Journal Publications from H-1B Visa Program; Employer Agrees to Pay $473,218 in Back Wages and $40,000 Penalty
07/13/2010 DOL Launches Online Registry of H-2A Agricultural Jobs
07/01/2010 Important Update for E-Verify Users: Program Redesign and Required Tutorial
05/14/2010 DOL Unveils New Tool to Help Employees and Small Businesses Understand Foreign Worker Certification
05/04/2010 Arizona Governor Signs Immigration Bill into Law President Obama Calls It Misguided
11/20/2009 ICE Assistant Secretary John Morton Announces 1,000 New Workplace Audits to Hold Employers Accountable for Their Hiring Practices
08/28/2009 New Form I-9 Released for Use by Employers
07/16/2009 652 Businesses Sent I-9 Audit Notices
07/14/2009 Krispy Kreme fined after I-9 audit
07/13/2009 Federal Contracts Only to Employers Who Use E-Verify to Check Employee Work Authorization
04/27/2009 E-Verify Federal Contractor Requirement Postponed Until June 30, 2009
04/13/2009 USCIS Reminds all U.S. Employers of Requirements to Use Revised Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification


Username: *

Password: *
Accept terms *
Login failed.
copyright 2000 - 2022 Curtis Communications, Inc. All rights reserved. | Access to the HR Care publications is subject to certain terms and conditions.
Learn about our online compliance training at www.hrclassroom.com